Saturday, May 19, 2012

Roadtest - Pfaff Expression 2.0 & Janome MC5200

So I had a couple hours of kid free time today to go check out potential sewing machines per my post here.  I decided to go to Chatswood Sewing Centre (CSC) because they sell and repair both Pfaff and Janome.  These were the two brands of interest to me and I wanted to talk to someone who wouldn't be too biased one way or the other.  I'm not sure whether Chatswood Sewing Centre is truly impartial since Shane the owner's main background is with Pfaff but the fact that he sells Janome means that he obviously thinks they are a good brand too.  Both Shane and Joanne the saleslady who helped me said that Pfaff was their preferred brand, in fact they thought the Expression 4.0 was the best machine in the shop.  At $2,699 (sale price) the 4.0 is over my price range.  The other thing they mentioned was that the internals of the Pfaff Expressions were built better than the Janomes.


Here's the two machines I tested
L-R: Janome MC5200; Pfaff Expression 2.0


I got Joanne to demo the Expression 2.0 for me (remember it's currently $1299 - $700 off).  Joanne got the machine set up for FMQ which included manually adjusting the tension which didn't take long, just a couple of tweaks of the knob down from 5 to 3.  She did a bit of FMQ and then let me have a go.  Considering I have had hardly any experience FMQ I did pretty well and it was fairly easy.  The speed had to be adjusted to medium but that was it.  I played around for a few minutes and was pleasantly surprised with how well my stitch length was.  So much better than what I'm getting with my current machine and the open toe (an extra) was quite large so you could see what you're sewing really well.  I would probably be happy to FMQ a quilt straight away with this machine.  I loved the 10" harp space, the menus looked pretty straight forward and I liked the fact that it told you everything you need to know for a particular stitch (which foot, stitch width and length etc) without having to pull out the manual.  It also has a nice little compartment at the front for holding all your feet neatly and it has a tie off function which you can do manually (with a little button above the presser foot) at the end of a seam or you could set it to auto and it would tie off your stitches at the beginning and at the end of a seam without you having to do anything.  Joanne also demo'd the buttonhole function, and it seemed surprisingly simple. The only negative thing I could pick was the plastic on the external body - to me it felt and looked cheap when you compare it to the Janome.




Pfaff Expression 2.0 (photo from here)


Shane and I talked about the Janome's, we narrowed down the selection to the MC5200 (I was told that it is very similar to the MC4900 QC minus a few stitches and the knee lift and a few hundred dollars).  I haven't checked the specs to see if there are any other differences.  In fact, he doesn't even stock the MC4900 QC because he said it doesn't sell that well.  The MC5200 is currently $999 ($500 off). It looked like an impressive Janome machine except the harp space was just a regular 7".  Again the menus looked pretty straight forward and the body looked nice and sturdy and there was a front compartment for feet same as the Pfaff but the open toe which doesn't come with the machine is small (it looked the same as the one I have already).  Joanne got the machine set up to FMQ and then handed it over to me.  I had a lot of trouble FMQ with this machine, the first pedal Joanne put on was small and probably not the one that comes with the machine.  I found the response time to be really poor, there was a definite delay between putting the foot down and the machine responding.  I found I had to put my foot down the whole way, after a second or two it would start working slowly and then go full speed.  We swapped the pedal to a different one and it was the same.  After a few minutes of FMQ I actually felt like I had had a work out.  Mentally and physically it had taxed me.  This was disappointing since I wanted to like the Janome more than the Pfaff.


Janome Memory Craft 5200 (photo from here)


So I am keen to go to another Janome dealer to try out the MC5200 and see if I have the same problems.  I would also like to at least check out the MC4900 QC for myself.  When we talked about the MC6600, CSC recommended buying the Elna version (supposed to be same machine but different badge and a fair bit cheaper - I think it was $1500).  I'm not so sure I would be comfortable with this.  The MC6600 at around $2500 is really out of my price range.




Pfaff Smarter (photo from here)


On the matter of the Pfaff Smarter 1100 Pro - I contacted Pfaff head office yesterday.  Maybe I just spoke to the receptionist, she wasn't too knowledgeable and was quite cagey about giving out any top secret information.  All I wanted to know was would this model be available in Australia since you can buy it in the US/Canada/UK and probably lots of other countries.  For starters she didn't even know what model I was talking about.  What I was told was that there have been some new machines released and no one will know what we will be getting until the Managing Director orders them.  However, they will be launching in August.  Not even the staff at CSC knew this!


So the search continues and I'm almost tempted to wait until August in case the Smarter is available (although it retails in the US with the Quilters Companion for around $1500 -  I'm assuming the price tag here will be around $2000).  To me the Smarter looks like a sturdier machine since it has more metal parts than the other Pfaffs.  I figure a good sewing machine is something that you buy every 10-20 years so it's best to do your homework and maybe it's worth paying that little bit extra (here we go I'm already willing to blow the budget!). 



11 comments:

  1. Sounds like a good bit of investigation - you will know when you find 'the one'!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I really enjoyed reading this. Good for you doing your research. I got my 4.0 when it was on special it was around 1800 from memory, that was a big reason I bought it. Isn't it amazing how they can reduce the price by hundreds of dollars. I've been to the Chatswood shop to get my old machine serviced, the guy impressed me by recognizing the model of my old 50s bernina even though it was in its case!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Good reasearch D. Wouldn't expect anything less from you! :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Same factory! Or the one next door. In fact just about every competing brand you look at these days comes out of the same factory so it's always interesting to hear sales people's bias towards the products. I say go for the one that feels best to you. So glad to see that the Pfaffs in your photos are not pinky-purple. I knew I couldn't look at that every day for 20 years when I bought mine which is what gave it to the 6600 when I was buying! (I know. How shallow am I? But colour is really important to me and I just couldn't look at the Pfaff's colours!)

    ReplyDelete
  5. They aren't from the same factory actually.... they WERE about 20 years ago but not anymore.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I just finished up machine shopping not that long ago. I pick up my new machine next week and can't wait.

    ReplyDelete
  7. glad you're doing so much research for this d - as you said its a big investment so you want to get something you really like - as for the 10 - 20 year life span my old elna is a 1984 model and is still going well - just had the motor rewound end of last year that cost me $150 - but not sure that the newer machines will last that long as they're built with more plastic parts - the mechanic who serviced mine said that it would last me another 25 years !

    ReplyDelete
  8. So have you made up your mind yet? I'm in a similar point with researching so I'd be interested to know what you ended up deciding on!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Michelle, you're a "no reply blogger" which means I couldn't email you the answer to this question. Yes, I have purchased a new sewing machine which I will be posting about very soon. Interestingly it is neither of the machines featured on this blog post!!

      dxx

      Delete
  9. I have always wanted one of these! Thanks for writing about it! Thanks for the article! It was a lot of good info. visit my site

    ReplyDelete
  10. I have the Pfaff 2.0 and LOVE LOVE LOVE it !! Remember , Pfaff is only one with built walking foot technology - probably why it was so easy for you right away !!

    ReplyDelete

I love getting comments! Thanks for stopping by.